The aggregate rating of Disney Magic is build on scorse given by the following portals:
| Aug / 24 | Sep / 24 | Oct / 24 | ||
| cruisetimetables.com | 4.0 / 36 | 4.2 / 37 | 4.0 / 30 | |
| cruisemapper.com | 4.0 / 1 | 4.0 / 1 | 4.0 / 1 | |
| cruiseline.com | / | 4.4 / 591 | 4.4 / 592 | |
| cruisedirect.com | 4.6 / 17 | 4.65 / 17 | 4.65 / 17 | |
| cruisecritic.com | 4.1 / 495 | 4.1 / 497 | 4.1 / |
Disney Magic is also ranked in: